Ira R. Herr Athletic Hall of Fame
A four-time All-MAC selection and a third-team All-American, Hoy was a member of the 1999 Middle Atlantic Conference Championship team. In 1999, the team advanced to the second round of the NCAA Division III Tournament. Hoy was also named to the All-Mid-Atlantic Region team three times. In his senior season, Hoy was named to the All-Mid-Atlantic Region First Team.