Baseball Year-by-Year Records

NAIA District 30 Champions (2): 1957, 1959
Middle Atlantic Conference Champions (7): 1964, 1974, 1975, 1976, 1988, 1993, 1997
Commonwealth Conference Champions (4): 2001, 2006, 2007, 2009
Landmark Conference Champions (2): 2017, 2022
NCAA Division III Baseball Championship Tournament Appearances (14): 1983, 1988, 1991, 1993, 1994, 2000, 2001, 2006, 2007, 2009, 2017, 2022, 2023, 2024

Note: The seasons of 1930, 1931, 1932, 1933, 1941 and 1949 all contained games the outcomes of which are unknown today.
 
Season Year Coach Record Conf. Record Conf. Finish Postseason
1 1930 * Kenneth Mateer 2-6 - -
2 1931 * Kenneth Mateer 3-6 - -
3 1932 * Ira R. Herr 2-5 - -
4 1933 * Ira R. Herr unknown - -
5 1934 Ira R. Herr 1-10 - -
6 1935 Ira R. Herr 2-9 - -
7 1936 Ira R. Herr 8-2 - -
8 1937 Ira R. Herr 9-1 - -
9 1938 Ira R. Herr 8-4-1 - -
10 1939 Ira R. Herr 6-7 - -
11 1940 Ira R. Herr 6-6 - -
12 1941* Ira R. Herr 10-4 - -
- 1942
No Season Played
- 1943
No Season Played
- 1944
No Season Played
13 1945 Ira R. Herr 3-7 - -
14 1946 Ira R. Herr 3-7 - -
15 1947 Ira R. Herr 6-8 - -
16 1948 Ira R. Herr 8-6 - -
17 1949* Ira R. Herr 7-9 - -
18 1950 Ira R. Herr 5-12 - -
19 1951 Ira R. Herr 11-8 - -
20 1952 Ira R. Herr 5-8 - -
21 1953 Ira R. Herr 9-5 - -
22 1954 Ira R. Herr 6-8-1 - -
23 1955 Ira R. Herr 11-6 - -
24 1956 Ira R. Herr 10-7 - -
25 1957 Ira R. Herr 14-6 - - NAIA District 30 Champions
26 1958 Ira R. Herr 10-6-1 - -
27 1959 Ira R. Herr 14-4 - - NAIA District 30 Champions
28 1960 Ira R. Herr 10-7 - -
29 1961 Ira R. Herr 12-6 - -
30 1962 Owen Wright 13-5 - -
31 1963 Owen Wright 11-9 - -
32 1964 Owen Wright 13-5 - - Middle Atlantic Conference Champions
33 1965 Owen Wright 8-9 - -
34 1966 Owen Wright 8-8 - -
35 1967 Owen Wright 7-10 - -
36 1968 Owen Wright 16-6 - -
37 1969 John Tulley 13-7 - -
38 1970 Owen Wright 8-6 - -
39 1971 Owen Wright 15-4 - -
40 1972 Owen Wright 14-4 - -
41 1973 Owen Wright 9-11 - -
42 1974 Owen Wright 15-5 - - Middle Atlantic Conference Champions
43 1975 Owen Wright 18-5 - - Middle Atlantic Conference Champions
ECAC Tournament Qualifier
44 1976 Owen Wright 17-7 - - Middle Atlantic Conference Champions
ECAC Tournament Qualifier
45 1977 Owen Wright 3-14-1 - -
46 1978 Owen Wright 13-8 - -
47 1979 Owen Wright 12-6 - -
48 1980 Owen Wright 8-14 - -
49 1981 Owen Wright 10-16 1-5 5th/5
50 1982 Owen Wright 18-11 - -
51 1983 Owen Wright 22-16 - - NCAA Division III Championship Qualifier
52 1984 Roger Hall 23-16 - -
53 1985 Roger Hall 19-16 - -
54 1986 Roger Hall 14-17 - -
55 1987 Roger Hall 24-17 - -
56 1988 John Gergic 31-7 - - Middle Atlantic Conference Champions
NCAA Division III Championship Qualifier
57 1989 John Gergic 20-12 - -
58 1990 John Gergic 21-11 - -
59 1991 John Gergic 26-9-1 - - NCAA Division III Championship Qualifier
60 1992 John Gergic 22-10-1 - -
61 1993 John Gergic 26-7 - - Middle Atlantic Conference Champions
NCAA Division III Championship Qualifier
62 1994 John Gergic 33-11 - - NCAA Division III Championship Qualifier
63 1995 John Gergic 28-11-1 - -
64 1996 John Gergic 21-17 - -
65 1997 Gary Pritchard 22-11 10-4 1st/8 Middle Atlantic Conference Champions
66 1998 Gary Pritchard 12-22-1 5-9 T-6th/8
67 1999 Gary Pritchard 27-11 12-2 1st/8 Middle Atlantic Conference Tournament Qualifier
68 2000 Matt Jones 26-14 9-5 1st/8 Middle Atlantic Conference Tournament Qualifier
NCAA Division III Championship Qualifier (Mid-Atlantic Regional)
69 2001 Matt Jones 19-19 8-6 T-2nd/8 Commonwealth Conference Champions
NCAA Division III Championship Qualifier (Mid-Atlantic Regional)
70 2002 Matt Jones 18-23 12-9 4th/8 Commonwealth Conference Tournament Qualifier
71 2003 Matt Jones 21-14 12-9 T-1st/8 Commonwealth Conference Runner-up
72 2004 Matt Jones 19-20 11-10 T-4th/8 Commonwealth Conference Tournament Qualifier
73 2005 Matt Jones 19-20-1 12-9 4th/8 Commonwealth Conference Runner-up
74 2006 Matt Jones 26-16-1 13-8 3rd/8 Commonwealth Conference Champions
NCAA Division III Championship Qualifier (Mideast Regional)
75 2007 Cliff Smith 23-18 13-8 2nd/8 Commonwealth Conference Champions
NCAA Division III Championship Qualifier (Mid-Atlantic Regional)
76 2008 Cliff Smith 26-12 10-2 1st/5 Commonwealth Conference Runner-up
77 2009 Cliff Smith 29-15 12-3 1st/6 Commonwealth Conference Champions
NCAA Division III Championship Qualifier (Mid-Atlantic Regional)
78 2010 Cliff Smith 24-16 11-7 3rd/7 Commonwealth Conference Runner-up
79 2011 Cliff Smith 19-19 10-8 4th/7 Commonwealth Conference Runner-up
80 2012 Cliff Smith 20-22 9-9 T-3rd/7 Commonwealth Conference Tournament Qualifier
81 2013 Cliff Smith 17-22 10-11 6th/8
82 2014 Cliff Smith 18-19 8-13 T-6th/8
83 2015 Cliff Smith 25-16 13-8 T-2nd/8 Landmark Conference Semifinals
84 2016 Cliff Smith 25-20 14-7 T-2nd/8 Landmark Conference Runner-up
85 2017 Cliff Smith 28-17 11-5 T-3rd/7 Landmark Conference Champions
NCAA Division III Championship Qualifier (Mid-Atlantic Regional)
86 2018 Adam Sheibley 21-19 12-6 T-1st/7 Landmark Conference Semifinals
87 2019 Adam Sheibley 14-26 7-11 6th/7
88* 2020 Adam Sheibley 8-3
89 2021 Adam Sheibley 17-11 13-9 3rd/7 Landmark Conference Runner-up
90 2022 Adam Sheibley 22-22 11-7 3rd/7 Landmark Conference Champions
NCAA Division III Tournament Qualifier
91 2023 Adam Sheibley 31-13 16-2 1st/7 Landmark Conference Semifinals
NCAA Division III Tournament At-Large Bid
92 2024 Adam Sheibley 33-14 18-6 1st/9 Landmark Conference Runner-Up
NCAA Division III Tournament At-Large Bid
NCAA Division III Harrisburg, Pa. Regional Runner-Up
93 2025 Adam Sheibley 29-13 19-5 2nd/9 Landmark Conference Semifinals
93 Seasons 10 Coaches 1,418-1,014-10
* Season canceled due to COVID-19
Updated 5/22/2024
Â