(Elizabethtown began competition in the Landmark Conference during the 2014-15 academic year)
 

2025 All-Landmark Conference
Player	Yr.	Team
Stefanos Billis	So.	2nd Team - Singles
2024 All-Landmark Conference
Player	Yr.	Team
Stefanos Billis	Fr.	Honorable Mention - Singles
2014 All-Commonwealth Conference
Player	Yr.	Team
Cole Turula	Sr.	1st Team
Michael Cannon	Jr.	2nd Team
2013 All-Commonwealth Conference
Player	Yr.	Team
Eric Fritzges	Sr.	1st Team
Josh Riehl	Sr.	1st Team
Cole Turula	Jr.	2nd Team
Paul Whitman	Sr.	2nd Team
Coach of the Year: Matt Helsel
2012 All-Commonwealth Conference
Player	Yr.	Team
Manrique Arrea	Sr.	1st Team
Josh Riehl	Jr.	1st Team
Eric Fritzges	Jr.	2nd Team
Paul Whitman	Jr.	2nd Team
Player of the Year: Manrique Arrea
2011 All-Commonwealth Conference
Player	Yr.	Team
Manrique Arrea	Jr.	1st Team
Josh Riehl	So.	1st Team
Billy Freitag	So.	2nd Team
Eric Fritzges	So.	2nd Team
Player of the Year: Manrique Arrea Rookie of the Year: Dylan Haefner Coach of the Year: Matt Helsel
2010 All-Commonwealth Conference
Player	Yr.	Team
Manrique Arrea	So.	1st Team
Josh Riehl	Fr.	1st Team
Bryan Metz	Jr.	2nd Team
Brok Walker	Sr.	2nd Team
Rookie of the Year: Josh Riehl
2009 All-Commonwealth Conference
Player	Yr.	Team
Manrique Arrea	Fr.	1st Team
Brok Walker	Jr.	1st Team
Jeff Kirkhoff	Sr.	2nd Team
Player of the Year: Manrique Arrea Rookie of the Year: Manrique Arrea
2008 All-Commonwealth Conference
Player	Yr.	Team
Jeff Kirkhoff	Jr.	1st Team
Brok Walker	So.	1st Team
Bryan Metz	Fr.	2nd Team
2007 All-Commonwealth Conference
Player	Yr.	Team
Maarten Albers	Fr.	1st Team
Ryan Knarr	Fr.	2nd Team
Brok Walker	Fr.	2nd Team
2006 All-Commonwealth Conference
Player	Yr.	Team
Per Roxendal	Fr.	1st Team
Hiep Pham	Fr.	2nd Team
2005 All-Commonwealth Conference
Player	Yr.	Team
Thomas Nyst	Fr.	1st Team
Greg Voshell	Sr.	1st Team
Yero Saponjian	Fr.	2nd Team
Rookie of the Year: Thomas Nyst Coach of the Year: Matt Helsel
2004 All-Commonwealth Conference
Player	Yr.	Team
Greg Voshell	Jr.	1st Team
Josh Miller	Jr.	2nd Team
2003 All-Commonwealth Conference
Player	Yr.	Team
Sude Dhillon	Sr.	1st Team
Greg Voshell	So.	2nd Team
2002 All-Commonwealth Conference
Player	Yr.	Team
Bill Miller	Sr.	-
2001 All-Commonwealth Conference
Player	Yr.	Team
Bill Miller	Jr.	-