2025 All-Landmark Conference
Player	Pos.	Team
Jess Dunn	3B	2nd Team
Maddie Reever	1B	2nd Team
2024 All-Landmark Conference
Player	Pos.	Team
Brooke Huczko	OF	2nd Team
Hannah Long	OF	Honorable Mention
2023 All-Landmark Conference
Player	Pos.	Team
No selections
2022 All-Landmark Conference
Player	Pos.	Team
Kadyn Crisswell	OF	1st Team
2021 All-Landmark Conference
Player	Pos.	Team
No selections
2020 All-Landmark Conference
Player	Pos.	Team
No All-Conference Teams selected due to COVID-19
2019 All-Landmark Conference
Player	Pos.	Team
Lindsey Fasolo	3B	1st Team
Emma Varrato	2B	1st Team
Christina Dark	DP	2nd Team
2018 All-Landmark Conference
Player	Pos.	Team
Kirstin Blass	SS	1st Team
Emma Varrato	2B	1st Team
Christina Dark	DP	1st Team
Landmark Co-Player of the Year: Kirstin Blass
2016 All-Landmark Conference
Player	Pos.	Team
Kelsey Brown	C	2nd Team
Christina Dark	1B	2nd Team
Emma Varrato	2B	2nd Team
2015 All-Landmark Conference
Player	Pos.	Team
Becky Becher	OF	2nd Team
Kirstin Blass	SS	2nd Team
Payton Marunich	2B	2nd Team
Laura Tomasetti	UTIL	2nd Team
Jessica White	1B	2nd Team
2014 All-Landmark Conference
Player	Pos.	Team
Kaylee Werner	SS	1st Team
Payton Marunich	OF	1st Team
2013 All-Commonwealth Conference
Player	Pos.	Team
Elly McCarthy	INF	2nd Team
Kaylee Werner	OF	Honorable Mention
2012 All-Commonwealth Conference
Player	Pos.	Team
Courtney Comstock	C	1st Team
Elly McCarthy	INF	1st Team
Julie Sebastian	UTIL	1st Team
Julie Sebastian	P	2nd Team
MAC Commonwealth Co-Player of the Year: Elly McCarthy
2011 All-Commonwealth Conference
Player	Pos.	Team
Courtney Comstock	C	1st Team
Elly McCarthy	UTIL	1st Team
2010 All-Commonwealth Conference
Player	Pos.	Team
Courtney Comstock	C	1st Team
Sarah Church	1B	1st Team
Paige Tanner	SS	2nd Team
Lindsey Cooper	OF	2nd Team
2009 All-Commonwealth Conference
Player	Pos.	Team
Marian Guzik	OF	1st Team
Paige Tanner	SS	1st Team
2008 All-Commonwealth Conference
Player	Pos.	Team
Alex Lee	P	2nd Team
Paige Tanner	SS	2nd Team
2007 All-Commonwealth Conference
Player	Pos.	Team
Alex Lee	P	1st Team
Kelli Thon	OF	1st Team
MAC Commonwealth Coach of the Year: Kathy Staib
2006 All-Commonwealth Conference
Player	Pos.	Team
Kelli Thon	OF	1st Team
2005 All-Commonwealth Conference
Player	Pos.	Team
Kelli Thon	OF	1st Team
2004 All-Commonwealth Conference
Player	Pos.	Team
Emily Morris	SS	1st Team
Kelli Thon	OF	2nd Team
2003 All-Commonwealth Conference
Player	Pos.	Team
Emily Morris	SS	1st Team
Michelle Morris	P	1st Team
Kirstyn Race	OF	2nd Team
Kate Sharkey	INF	2nd Team
MAC Commonwealth Co-Pitcher of the Year: Michelle Morris
2002 All-Commonwealth Conference
Player	Pos.	Team
Emily Morris	SS	1st Team
Michelle Morris	P	1st Team
2001 All-Commonwealth Conference
Player	Pos.	Team
Emily Morris	SS	2nd Team
2000 All-Commonwealth Conference
Player	Pos.	Team
Kelly Spence	SS	1st Team
Kristy Nowell	OF	2nd Team
1999 MAC Commonwealth League
Player	Pos.	Team
Vikki Detweiler	3B	1st Team
1998 MAC Commonwealth League
Player	Pos.	Team
Lora Crawford	OF	1st Team
Kelly Spence	3B	2nd Team
Kristy Nowell	OF	2nd Team
1997 MAC Commonwealth League
Player	Pos.	Team
Emily Weibel	DP	1st Team
1996 MAC Commonwealth League
Player	Pos.	Team
Jennifer Kimmel	C	2nd Team
Stephanie Maurer	SS	2nd Team
1995 MAC Commonwealth League
Player	Pos.	Team
Jodi Kuehn	3B	1st Team
Mary Dougherty	OF	2nd Team
Sallie Mohr	P	2nd Team
1994 MAC Commonwealth League
Player	Pos.	Team
Kim Hampson	C	1st Team
Sallie Mohr	P	2nd Team
Val Degler	P	2nd Team
Jodi Kuehn	3B	2nd Team
Audrey Zawislak	OF	2nd Team
1993 MAC Northwest League
Player	Pos.	Team
Kim Matlack	P
Kim Hampson	C
Monica Lehman	SS
1992 MAC Northwest League
Player	Pos.	Team
Amy Kline	3B
Monica Lehman	SS
Debra Lesher	1B
1991 MAC Northwest League
Player	Pos.	Team
Debra Lesher	1B
Lisa Boden	RF
Bonnie Williams	DP
1990 MAC Northwest League
Player	Pos.	Team
Karen Barclay	C
Debra Lesher	1B
1989 MAC Northwest League
Player	Pos.	Team
Lori Lobb	SS
Kim Cahill	OF
1988 MAC Northwest League
Player	Pos.	Team
Tammy McDonald	P
Karen Barclay	C
Lori Lobb	SS
Colleen Cochran	LF
Kim Cahill	CF
1987 MAC Northern Division
Player	Pos.	Team
Tammy McDonald	P
Tory Weinhold	C
Bonnie Bair	2B
Kathy Crowley	3B
Lori Lobb	SS
Kim Cahill	OF
1986 MAC Northern Division
Player	Pos.	Team
Tammy McDonald	P
Cathy Crowley	3B
Lori Lobb	SS
Sheri Adie	OF
Colleen Cahill	OF
Ellen Weber	DH
1985 MAC Northern Division
Player	Pos.	Team
Bonnie Bair	INF
Carol Willoughby	C